If you’ve already done your Ancestry DNA test, you most likely see a section called a “Low Confidence Region” that is listed just below your major ethnicities. Many people automatically assume that because it says “Low Confidence” that is isn’t accurate. The reality is that sometimes it isn’t accurate, and sometimes it is. That’s why they call it low confidence – it’s because their software algorithm can’t be sure.
Basically, it means you just have a small amount of DNA from that region. On Ancestry’s help pages, it says that any region that has less than 4.5% will show up on the low confidence section, but I have found that this is not always the case. In fact, on my own DNA test results, I have the Iberian Peninsula as a Low Confidence region, but it shows that I have 6%.
So how can you tell whether it is just “background noise”, incorrect, or if you actually do have ethnicity from those regions showing as a lower percentage in your DNA? I’m so glad you asked, because I have some suggestions and ideas that might help you figure these mysteries out on your own.
It’s really important to explore these lower percentage regions because if you ignore them, you might miss some really important information about your family history. In addition, learning about those regions might help you build your family tree in ways that you would have otherwise overlooked.
For the purpose of my explanations, we will look at the low confidence regions on my personal DNA test results:
Do the low confidence regions match with what you already know about your family tree?
The first thing that you should do when you see those results is compare them to what you already know about your family history. For example:
I only showed 2% Europe West, but I know that my father’s paternal grandmother was German, born in the U.S. to two German parents. Also, my mother’s maternal grandmother was also born in the U.S. to two German parents. In a perfect DNA inheritance scenario, I should have inherited 12.5% from each great-grandmother, leaving me with a whopping 25% Europe West DNA.
In the real world, however, DNA doesn’t always get passed down in the exact percentages that we would expect it to. Each child inherits 50% of their DNA from each parent, and that means that there is 50% of each of your parents’ DNA that you didn’t inherit. Going back to my Europe West example, I am lucky that I can actually look at my parents DNA results (I’ve had them tested), and can see how much Europe West they had.
It turns out that my mother has absolutely no Europe West ethnicity whatsoever, despite what her family tree says. My father, on the other hand, has 43% Europe West. Obviously, I couldn’t inherit any from my mother since she didn’t have any to begin with. But if my father has 43%, why don’t I show more than just 2%? It turns out that my father has DNA from many other places, such as Scandinavia, Iberian Peninsula, and Ireland. So when I got the 50% of DNA that I inherited, I just inherited a lot of that other stuff, and not so much of the Europe West DNA.
I just took a quick peek at my mother’s full brother, and it turns out that he only shows 1% Europe West in his family tree. This leads met to the next item for your consideration:
Is there something (like a surprise or a secret) in your family tree that you don’t know about?
Is it possible that the reason that my mother doesn’t show any Europe West DNA is because her maternal grandmother wasn’t really German, or was only half German? I’m sure you can use your imagination to figure out ways that this could have happened. And hey, in the DNA world, we’ve seen crazier stories than that. In my own personal family tree, I still don’t know why my mother doesn’t have any Europe West DNA. A mystery for another day.
There are many, many reasons that family histories might try to hide situations that were disagreeable at the time. Maybe there was an unwed mother, and the family had her marry someone and take the husband’s name, when biologically the child belonged to someone else. Sometimes, children were adopted because one or both of their parents died. It’s also hard to imagine, but our ancestors were also human and fallible, and sometimes they had children with people who weren’t their spouse.
In the United States, people who consider themselves to be white are often surprised to find small amounts of Native American or African ethnicities in their DNA. For example, my mother has Southeastern Bantu in her low confidence region. This means that somewhere, a long time ago, I likely have an ancestor – or even more than one – from this region of Africa. We all know the history of our country, and it’s likely that the grandchildren and great-grandchildren of this ancestor might have felt it advantageous to hide/forget/ignore this aspect of their history.
One thing that I’ve learned through this whole process is that my family history is just that. I can’t judge my ancestors for these types of decisions, but I can try to understand them better. Though, it sure would be easier for me and my research if they would have passed this information down to me.
Are low confidence regions located in the same geographic area or near where you know that your ancestors are from?
This is a pretty simple concept, but it is often overlooked. Sometimes people are expecting a particular ethnicity to come back, or expecting a higher percentage, and they find that they either have none of the expected ethnicity or a smaller amount, and then show an unexpected ethnicity. One very common reason – and usually the most likely explanation for any discrepancy – is that there was just lots of mixture between regional populations. This cause the “borders” between the typical ethnic regions to “blur” and overlap.
We can still use my mother’s lack of Europe West DNA as an example. My mother shows 63% Europe East DNA, which is actually higher than I would have expected her to have, since she had only two grandparents who were Eastern European or of 100% Eastern European descent. When I click on the Eastern European section on Ancestry DNA’s map (on my mom’s ethnicity estimate screen), it takes me to a new page where it explains that Eastern European DNA is often found in Germany.
While I don’t know 100% for sure, this is a very simple explanation for my mother’s 0% Europe West DNA result. Most likely, my German great-grandmother was descended from people who originally lived in Eastern Europe. They might have slowly migrated west over the generations, maybe intermarrying with people with similar ethnic and linguistic backgrounds.
Have Your Other Relatives Tested?
One of the best ways to figure out where your trace ancestry comes from is to test older relatives, like your parents, aunts, uncles, grandparents, or even great aunts or great uncles. This has worked for me, as I have been able to have great uncles on multiple sides of my family do an Ancestry DNA test, as well as my parents and grandmother. Using this method, I have been able to figure out which side of the family the trace ancestry came from, and many times it shows up in a much larger percentage in my older relatives – meaning that it really isn’t as far back as it initially appeared.
It’s best to test full aunts, uncles, grandparents, and full great aunts and uncles, since all of their DNA ancestors are your ancestors, as well. This means that all of their DNA matches are also family to you, and that their ethnicity results are also your ethnicity results, even if you don’t show all of those things in your DNA. Buying DNA for relatives, or convincing them to buy a DNA test can be tough, but it is worth the investment.
If you do end up deciding to buy another kit, you can use this link, which gives me a small commission (at no extra cost to you): Discover the family story your DNA can tell. Thanks for helping me support this website!
Have you uploaded your DNA to Gedmatch in order to get alternative ethnicity estimates?
Another really cool – and free! – way to get a “second opinion” about your ethnicity estimates, and especially your low confidence regions is to download your DNA from Ancestry (or whichever company you used to test) and upload it to Gedmatch. It’s completely free, and there are many additional ethnicity estimate calculators on that website that can help you determine if there is something that you are overlooking.
For example, there was a belief in my family that we had Native American ancestry. As of yet, I have not found any genealogical evidence of that. The grandparent in question had their DNA tested in Ancestry and found less than 1% Native American DNA. Most people would immediately conclude that it must not be true.
The only problem with me just “letting it go” is that this particular line of the family – all of her lines – have been in the United States for centuries. Since the 1600s in many cases. Considering that there are literally thousands of ancestors that far back, it doesn’t seem improbable at all that at least one of my ancestors could have been Native American.
With this in mind, and with the “trace” (read: less than 1%) Native American DNA result from Ancestry, I was able to analyze her DNA on a few different Gedmatch “admixture” calculators. One particular calculator that has a good reputation for being extra sensitive to Native American DNA found that my grandmother had a little over 1% of Native American DNA, and a little under 1% East Asian DNA, which is often interpreted as Native American.
As with most things like this, I still don’t know for sure if the Gedmatch calculator solved any mystery for me – and still, I have to use actual records to really know the truth. It’s still a great tool for getting the most from your results and getting to the bottom of those smaller percentage ethnicities.
Have you searched through your close and distant DNA matches on Ancestry DNA to see if you find people with only that ethnicity listed?
This is a time consuming option, but it’s one that you should definitely consider doing little by little. My daughter shows 2% European Jewish. If you can recall, I only show 1%. Considering the fact that it is statistically unlikely that she inherited my whole 1% of European Jewish, this means that she probably got it all from her father. He likely has much more than that. In addition, her paternal grandmother’s maiden name is Abraham (translated into English from Spanish). Sure enough, she has distant cousin DNA matches that are 100% European Jewish and don’t share me as a match. I don’t know the how/why yet, and maybe I never will, but you can definitely learn a lot about whether your low confidence region ethnicities are “real” or not by checking out your family/cousin matches.
If you’ve stuck with me this far, thanks so much for stopping by and reading. If you have any questions or comments about anything that I’ve written, I really want to hear from you in the comments.
Have a great day!